EDIT MAIN
Plus_blue
Year Male Female
1968 Jim Leggott
1969 Bill Nott
1970 Charles Tilson
1971 Gregg Leggott
1972 Garold Leggott
1973 Dick Slater
1974 Mark Boyle
1975 Karol McKenzie
1976 Marvin Rhodes
1977 Toby Boss
1978 Gary Monter
1979 David Leggott
1980 Kim Jorges
1981 Monte Holl Lori Monter
1982 Eden Whitten Judy Misterek
1983 Matt Boyle Amy Bossung
1984 Jeff Wade Michelle Walston
1985 Roy Brush Jana Huerta
1986 Jonathon Lucas Mary Jane Houlden
1987 No one eligible Jill Owens
1988 Cory Holl Hope Schurman
1989 Daren Hatch No one eligible
1990 Robb Owens Cindy Salisbury
1991 Scott Franzen Jennifer Lerdall
1992 David Essman, Shannon Poggendorf Jill Brell, Michelle Mues
1993 Brian Schmeeckle No one eligible
1994 Anthony Schutz Paulie Osterberg
1995 Tim Franzen Karen Snyder
1996 Eric Hilton Robin Bredenkamp
1997 Brant Arends Amber Evans
1998 D.J. O'Donnell Jill Schultheiss
1999 Josh Hagan Davina Leezer
2000 Andy Hughes Codina Oaklund
2001 Rob Sjomeling Sara Baldonado
2002 Chris Evans Danielle Sjomeling
2003 Kelly Cooksley Amanda Remmenga
2004 Nolan Freeman Morgan Baldonado
2005 Joe Pickinpaugh Chelsey Bellamy
2006 B.J. Holscher Sydney Cooksley
2007 Stephen Schutz Britney Zeller
2008 Bryson Mahlberg Kylea Foss
2009 Cody Barnes, Kayle Barnes Jessica Flint
2010 Braeden Banzhaf Bailey Mahlberg
2011 Wyatt Robb Molly Weissert
2012 Walter Flint, Jonathan Weber Nicole Daake
2013 Spencer Gydesen Rachel Mahlberg
2014 Jacob Schmeeckle, Blake Summer No one eligible
2015 Zack Hackbart Anna Eggers
2016 No one eligible Tobie Carlberg, Cassie Jorges
2017 Jake Gydesen, Kallen Nickell Jordan Hagan, Katie Kleine
2018 No one eligible Tiffany Dickau

Apparently before 1981, the award was given to either a male or female athlete.